A driver's car with a glorious naturally aspirated V8 that won Ward's 10 Best Engines twice. Depreciation has made these remarkably affordable, but timing chain tensioner failure around 80,000-100,000 km is the elephant in the room - a €5,000-8,000 repair requiring engine removal. If that's been done or you budget for it, the rest of the car is mechanically robust. Regular oil changes are critical. Manual gearbox models with documented service history are the sweet spot.
Chain guides and tensioners wear, causing cold start rattle, then catastrophic valve damage · more· less
The timing chain itself rarely fails - it's the plastic guides, tensioners, and cam adjusters that wear out or break. Mean average failure occurs around 100,000 km, though some fail as early as 60,000 km and others survive past 150,000 km. Symptoms include rattle on cold start (1-2 seconds is normal, more than 5 seconds is concerning). Poor oil maintenance accelerates failure. The timing chains are located at the REAR of the engine facing the firewall, requiring complete engine removal for service. When tensioners fail completely, broken guide pieces can wedge between chain and sprocket causing it to jump - this leads to piston-valve contact and catastrophic engine damage requiring full rebuild. Preventive replacement at 80,000-100,000 km is strongly recommended. Parts cost €2,000-3,000, labor adds another €3,000-5,000 due to engine removal. RS4 with FSI direct injection doesn't suffer this issue.
Dual mass flywheel failure (manual)€1,200 - €2,500
DMF springs wear, causing rattling on startup and gear changes · more· less
Manual transmission models use a dual mass flywheel to smooth out vibrations from the V8. The DMF has internal springs that wear over time, typically becoming audible around 100,000-120,000 km. First symptom is a rattling sound on cold start that goes away when you press the clutch. As it worsens, you'll hear rattling during gear changes and when releasing the clutch. Replace immediately once rattling starts - a failed DMF can damage the clutch and transmission. Labor is significant (6.5-7.5 hours) due to Quattro drivetrain. When replacing, always do clutch at the same time. OEM parts (LUK) cost €400-600 for DMF + clutch kit. Independent specialists charge €1,200-1,500 total, Audi dealers €2,000-2,500. The Quattro system adds complexity and cost compared to FWD models.
Excessive oil consumption€2,000 - €4,000
Valve stem seals wear, causing blue smoke on cold start and heavy oil burning · more· less
The 4.2L V8 burns some oil even when healthy - checking and topping up between services is normal. However, excessive consumption (>1L per 1,000 km) with blue smoke puffs on cold start indicates worn valve stem seals. Oil pools around valve stems when engine is off, then burns on startup. Spark plugs show heavy carbon buildup. Most noticeable after car sits overnight. Typically appears after 80,000-120,000 km. A compression test rules out other causes - good compression confirms it's valve stem seals. Repair requires pulling camshafts (which means chain sprockets come off) but can be done without removing cylinder heads. JHM head gasket kit includes all 40 valve stem seals plus gaskets and bolts. Many mechanics prefer removing heads for better access, adding to cost. Independent specialists: €2,000-2,500, dealers: €3,000-4,000. Some owners opt to simply monitor oil and top up, living with blue smoke rather than expensive repair.
Control arm bushing wear€800 - €2,500
Multi-link suspension bushings deteriorate, causing clunking and vague steering · more· less
B7 S4 uses a sophisticated multi-link suspension with small ball joints that are its weak point. Bushings typically worn by 70,000 km, definitely need attention by 100,000-120,000 km. Symptoms: clunking over bumps (especially while turning), steering play/vagueness, squeaking on uneven surfaces. If severely worn, tire wear becomes uneven and car may pull to one side. Independent specialists recommend replacing entire control arms rather than pressing in new bushings - the ball joints get sticky after 10+ years and pressing can damage arms. Front suspension has 4 arms that commonly need replacement. OEM/Genuine parts recommended (Lemförder, Meyle HD). DIY with quality parts: €400-600. Independent shop: €800-1,200. All four corners at dealer: €2,000-2,500. Upgraded options available from 034 Motorsport with density line bushings for firmer ride.
B6/B7 S4 has auxiliary radiators on both sides that are notorious for leaks. Each costs just over €100 and is DIY-friendly. Common leak point is where coolant temp sensor mounts - rubber O-ring fails. Also check metal coolant pipes that run under intake manifold (part 079121481G with N90806302 O-ring). Look for pink crystals under manifold - telltale sign of coolant leak. Another issue is silver pipe running front of oil pan - held by one bolt with washer and O-ring seal that deteriorates. Thermostat failure is also common, causing either overcooling (stuck open, poor heater performance) or overheating (stuck closed). Thermostat alone: €400-600 parts + €400-600 labor. The whole cooling system uses plastic components that become brittle with age and heat cycles. Always flush entire system thoroughly when replacing water pump - old coolant degrades seals prematurely. Budget €600-1,000 for addressing cooling system issues at independent shop.
Ignition coil pack failure€200 - €500
Very common failure, causes misfires and rough idle · more· less
One of the most common B6/B7 S4 issues. Symptoms: check engine light with misfire codes, flashing CEL, rough idle, loss of power. V8 has 8 coil packs, one per cylinder. When one fails, that cylinder stops firing. Diagnosis is easy: swap suspected coil to another cylinder - if misfire follows the coil, it's bad. OEM coils cost about €45 each from ECS Tuning or FCP Euro. This is a 5-minute DIY job - coils mounted on top of engine, easily accessible. Many owners replace all 8 preventively with spark plugs at 80,000-100,000 km. All 8 coils + 8 spark plugs: €400-600 parts + labor if not DIY. Dealers charge €480+ but it's unnecessary - parts are cheap and installation is simple. Failing coils allow unburned fuel into exhaust, potentially damaging catalytic converter (€1,500-2,500 to replace), so fix immediately. Keep spare coil in boot - they fail without warning and car runs poorly on 7 cylinders.
Window regulator failure€200 - €600
Window cables fray, causing grinding noise and stuck windows · more· less
Common problem on Audi models after 80,000-100,000 km. Driver's door usually fails first due to most frequent use. Symptoms: grinding noise when operating window, window moves slowly or gets stuck, window only goes up/down partially. Typically it's the regulator (cable mechanism) not the motor - if you hear motor clicking, motor is fine. Cables become frayed and binding restricts movement. Cables are integral to regulator assembly and cannot be replaced separately - entire regulator must be changed. Using OEM or quality aftermarket parts important - cheap regulators fail prematurely. Not particularly complex repair but requires door panel removal and careful reassembly to prevent rattles. OEM regulator: €150-250. Labor: 1-1.5 hours. Total at independent shop: €300-450 per window. If only one-touch auto up/down stops working (but manual operation works), it's usually the window switch (€50-100) not regulator. Can reset one-touch: fully open window, hold button 10 seconds, then fully close and hold button 10 seconds.
Affordable performance with one major concern
The B7 S4's 4.2L V8 is mechanically sound apart from the timing chain tensioner issue. If that service has been done (or you budget €5,000-8,000 for it), the rest is manageable. Regular oil changes with correct spec oil (5W-30) are critical. Manual gearbox models are more reliable than later DSG automatics. These cars have depreciated heavily due to overhyped reliability concerns, making them excellent value if you buy wisely with full service history and budget for the chain service.
Pre-Purchase Inspection Checklist
General checks
Service history
Complete records essential, especially oil changes. Verify correct oil spec (5W-30 or better).
Tires
Check tread depth, age (date codes), uneven wear. Original size 235/40R18 or 255/35R19.
Cold start
Must start completely cold. Listen for timing chain rattle first 1-30 seconds.
Accident history
Carfax/AutoCheck to verify no accidents. Check for paint mismatch, panel gaps.
Test drive
Minimum 30 minutes including highway speeds. Test full rev range.
Specific for this vehicle
Cold start timing chain rattle check
CRITICAL: Engine must be completely cold (overnight). Listen first 30 seconds. 1-2 seconds rattle is acceptable. 5+ seconds indicates worn tensioners. Ask if chain service has been done and verify receipts.
Check for blue smoke on cold start
Watch exhaust on cold start. Blue puff indicates valve stem seals. Ask about oil consumption between services.
Inspect all coolant hoses and auxiliary radiators
Look under hood for pink/green residue or crystals. Check coolant level. Auxiliary radiators on both sides - look for wetness or staining.
Test suspension for clunking and play
Drive over speed bumps while turning steering. Listen for clunks. On highway, feel for steering vagueness - indicates worn control arm bushings.
Manual gearbox: test clutch and listen for DMF rattle
Press clutch on cold start - DMF rattle should disappear. Test clutch engagement point (shouldn't be at floor or ceiling). Feel for shuddering on take-off.
Scan for fault codes with VCDS/OBD2
Check for stored misfire codes (coil packs), cam correlation faults (timing chain), boost/fuel pressure codes. Pending codes are red flags.
Check for Takata airbag recall completion
Affects 2005-2008 models. Verify with Audi dealer using VIN.
Intake camshaft wear (early production)TSB - check with dealer
Fuel pressure regulator fault codesTSB - not safety critical
Steering wheel vibration on brakingTSB - warped rotors
Contact Audi dealer with VIN to verify all recalls completed. TSBs (Technical Service Bulletins) document common problems and solutions but are not mandatory safety recalls. Check NHTSA.gov or carcomplaints.com for complete TSB list by VIN.
Warranty Status
Factory warrantyExpired on all B7 S4s
Timing chain serviceNot covered by any warranty
Extended warrantyAvailable from third parties
All 2005-2008 S4s are outside their original factory warranty. Extended warranties are available from third-party providers but typically exclude timing chain work and pre-existing issues. Best protection is thorough pre-purchase inspection and maintenance fund for timing chain service if not already done.
This report is for informational purposes only and does not constitute professional advice. Estimates may be inaccurate. Always have a qualified specialist inspect the vehicle before purchase. We accept no liability for decisions made based on this information.